Our Selection Process

Finding the right doctor shouldn’t be a gamble with your health. At Top3Doctors.com, we’ve developed a comprehensive selection process that identifies healthcare providers who demonstrate exceptional medical qualifications, clinical excellence, and professional integrity. Every physician in our network undergoes a rigorous, multi-layered evaluation designed to ensure you connect with only the most qualified, board-certified medical professionals.

Medical Board Review Committee & Independent Advisory Oversight

Our Expert Review Panels

Our selection process operates under the guidance of two distinguished panels of medical professionals who bring decades of combined clinical experience across multiple specialties. These committees serve as the cornerstone of our credentialing process, ensuring every doctor meets the highest standards of medical excellence.

Committee Composition

Our review committees include:

• Board-certified physicians from major medical specialties
• Independent medical professionals with no financial relationships to reviewed physicians
• Experienced medical administrators and patient advocacy representatives
• Quality assurance specialists with healthcare backgrounds

Independent Medical Advisory Board Standards

Our Independent Medical Advisory Board ensures:

• Objective Assessment: No financial relationships exist with reviewed physicians
• Clinical Expertise: Specialty-specific evaluation by qualified peers
• Quality Standards: Consistent application of excellence criteria across all specialties
• Professional Integrity: Verification of ethical practice standards

Our 25-Point Verification System

Phase 1: Basic Credentialing & Primary Source Verification (Days 1-3)

Medical License Verification

We start by confirming that every physician maintains active, unrestricted medical licenses in all states where they practice. This includes:

• Verifying license issue dates and renewal compliance
• Checking for any restrictions, limitations, or probationary status
• Cross-referencing with state medical board databases
• Validating multi-state licenses where applicable

Board Certification Review

We conduct direct verification with the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS) to confirm:

• Initial board certification dates and specialty areas
• Current certification status and recertification compliance
• Sub-specialty certifications and fellowship training
• Certification maintenance requirements and continuing education
• Maintenance of Certification (MOC) status

Medical Education Verification

Every physician’s educational background undergoes thorough verification, including:

• Confirmation of graduation from accredited medical schools
• Validation of residency program completion and performance
• Verification of fellowship training in specialized areas
• Cross-checking training program accreditation status
• Review of academic performance and honors

Phase 2: Background Investigation & Professional Standing (Days 4-7)

Disciplinary Action Review

We conduct comprehensive background investigations that include:

• Searching state medical board disciplinary records
• Reviewing hospital peer review actions and sanctions
• Checking malpractice case history and settlement records
• Investigating professional liability claims or judgments
• Querying the National Practitioner Data Bank
• Reviewing complete license history and any disciplinary actions

Hospital Affiliations and Privileges

We verify each physician’s hospital relationships by:

• Confirming active medical staff appointments at multiple facilities
• Validating current clinical privileges and department memberships
• Reviewing any privilege restrictions or departmental actions
• Checking admitting privileges and surgical credentials
• Assessing the quality of affiliated medical institutions
• Reviewing peer ratings from hospital medical staff

Phase 3: Clinical Excellence & Professional Assessment (Days 8-11)

Peer Professional References

We gather comprehensive peer evaluations by:

• Collecting confidential evaluations from medical colleagues
• Reviewing professional society memberships and leadership roles
• Assessing participation in medical committees and quality initiatives
• Evaluating contributions to medical education and research
• Confirming hospital credentialing office recommendations
• Validating professional society memberships

Patient Safety Record & Clinical Outcomes

Our patient safety evaluation includes:

• Comprehensive malpractice history review
• Patient safety incident analysis
• Hospital quality metrics assessment
• Analysis of patient satisfaction scores from verified healthcare facilities
• Examination of surgical success rates and complication statistics

Phase 4: Excellence Evaluation & Ongoing Development (Days 12-14)

Clinical Performance Analysis

We assess each physician’s clinical excellence through:

• Evaluating adherence to evidence-based medicine protocols
• Analyzing treatment success rates where available
• Reviewing quality improvement initiatives participation
• Assessing evidence-based practice implementation
• Examining patient satisfaction scores

Continuing Professional Development

We verify ongoing professional commitment by reviewing:

• Continuing medical education compliance
• Participation in medical conferences and specialty training
• Commitment to staying current with medical advances
• Teaching responsibilities and academic appointments

Multi-Specialty Expert Review Process

Specialty-Specific Evaluations

Each physician undergoes evaluation by board-certified peers in their specific field of practice.

Internal Medicine & Primary Care

For primary care physicians, we evaluate:

• Preventive care protocol expertise
• Chronic disease management capabilities
• Patient communication excellence
• Care coordination skills

Surgical Specialties

Surgeons undergo additional scrutiny including:

• Surgical volume and outcome metrics analysis
• Complication rates evaluation
• Innovation and technique mastery assessment
• Patient safety protocols adherence verification

Subspecialties

Subspecialty physicians are assessed for:

• Advanced training verification
• Cutting-edge treatment familiarity
• Research and publication contributions
• Professional society involvement

Patient-Centered Selection Criteria

Communication Excellence

Beyond clinical credentials, we evaluate physicians’ ability to:

• Demonstrate exceptional patient communication skills
• Show cultural competency and sensitivity
• Provide language proficiency where needed
• Excel in patient education capabilities

Accessibility and Availability

We assess each physician’s commitment to patient access through:

• Reasonable appointment availability
• Emergency coverage arrangements
• Electronic communication capabilities
• Insurance acceptance verification

Ongoing Monitoring and Re-Verification

Quarterly Reviews

Our commitment to excellence continues after initial selection through regular monitoring that includes:

• Tracking new disciplinary actions or license changes
• Updating hospital affiliation and privilege status
• Reviewing new malpractice claims or professional issues
• Verifying continued board certification compliance
• Monitoring license status through national databases
• Assessing ongoing patient feedback

Annual Re-Assessment & Re-credentialing

Every twelve months, we conduct comprehensive re-evaluation by:

• Completing full credential re-verification
• Renewing all professional credentials
• Updating clinical performance metrics when available
• Reassessing peer standing and professional reputation
• Collecting updated peer references
• Conducting quality metrics reassessment
• Confirming continued adherence to our selection standards

What We Don’t Accept – Strict Exclusion Criteria

Financial Factors We Reject

We maintain our integrity by refusing:

• Pay-to-Play Models: Physicians cannot purchase inclusion in our network
• Direct payment or fees from physicians
• Marketing-Based Selection: Advertising spending has no influence on selection
• Premium membership purchases or marketing campaign investments

Commercial Relationships We Avoid

We do not consider:

• Business partnerships or affiliations with physicians
• Referral fee arrangements
• Equipment or service vendor relationships
• Insurance network participation incentives

Strict Medical Exclusions

We automatically exclude physicians with:

• Self-Reported Credentials: All information must undergo independent verification
• Expired Certifications: Only current, active certifications are accepted
• Any history of medical license suspension or revocation
• Unresolved malpractice cases with patient safety implications
• Failure to maintain board certification requirements
• Disciplinary actions by state medical boards
• Criminal convictions related to medical practice

Consumer Protection & Transparency Measures

Independent Verification Process

All credential verification is conducted through independent, third-party sources including:

• National Practitioner Data Bank queries
• Direct state medical board verification
• Hospital credentialing office confirmation
• Professional society membership validation

Documentation Standards & Accountability

We maintain the highest standards of accountability by:

• Keeping detailed records of every verification step
• Creating audit trails supporting each physician selection
• Documenting rationale for inclusion or exclusion decisions
• Preserving evidence supporting ongoing monitoring activities
• Conducting external auditing firm annual reviews
• Verifying process compliance regularly

Patient Access & Communication

We ensure transparency through:

• Providing clear information about our selection criteria
• Explaining our verification process upon patient request
• Maintaining open communication channels for questions
• Responding promptly to concerns about featured physicians

Technology and Innovation Integration

Electronic Health Records & Digital Capabilities

We evaluate physicians’ technological proficiency including:

• Electronic health record (EHR) system proficiency
• Patient portal utilization capabilities
• Telemedicine platform competencies
• Digital health tool integration

Evidence-Based Practice Implementation

We assess physicians’ commitment to modern medicine through:

• Latest treatment protocol adoption
• Clinical guideline adherence
• Quality improvement participation
• Outcome measurement commitment

Your Assurance of Quality

What Our Selection Guarantees

When you see a physician featured on Top3Doctors.com, you can be confident they have:

✓ Current Board Certification from recognized medical specialty boards
✓ Active Medical License with clean disciplinary record
✓ Hospital Privileges at accredited medical facilities
✓ Peer Recognition from fellow medical professionals
✓ Patient Safety Record meeting our stringent standards
✓ Continuing Education compliance with ongoing learning requirements
✓ Independent Medical Advisory Board Approval – 100% of selected physicians

Selection Statistics & Performance Metrics

Our Track Record

Our comprehensive evaluation process delivers measurable results:

• Average Evaluation Time: 14 days per physician
• Verification Points: 25+ individual checks per candidate
• Medical Advisory Board Review: 100% of selected physicians
• Re-Verification Cycle: Every 12 months
• Quality Assurance: Multi-tier oversight process
• Independent Third-Party Verification: 100% of all credentials

Commitment to Continuous Improvement

Evolving with Medical Standards

Our selection process continues to evolve with advancing medical standards and changing healthcare needs. We regularly:

• Update criteria based on the latest medical board requirements
• Incorporate patient feedback into our selection metrics
• Adapt to new credentialing best practices
• Enhance verification technology and processes
• Refine our methodology based on patient and provider feedback

Contact Our Selection Team

Get Answers to Your Questions

Have questions about our selection process or want to verify information about a featured physician? Our selection team maintains complete transparency about our methodology and welcomes patient inquiries.

Email: selections@top3doctors.com

Hours: Monday – Friday, 9 AM – 6 PM PST
Response Time: Within 24 hours for all inquiries

---

Top3Doctors.com is committed to transparency in our selection process. Our methodology is continuously refined to maintain the highest standards of medical professional evaluation. While we maintain the highest standards for physician inclusion, patients are encouraged to verify credentials independently and make informed decisions about their healthcare providers. We do not provide medical advice and recommend consulting with qualified healthcare professionals for all medical concerns.